The Fed Is Repeating Its Lehman Mistake

Its chairman was in the room in 2008. He voted to hold rates the day after Lehman failed.

Premium Members: There's a short portfolio update at the top of the Premium section below, then Friday's Buy Alert, exactly as it ran on November 13.

On September 16, 2008, the morning after Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy, the Federal Reserve met in Washington.

The committee voted to leave interest rates at 2%. The vote was unanimous. The statement it put out that afternoon said the risks to growth and the risks of inflation were "both of significant concern."

One of the governors who voted that day was 38 years old. Six weeks earlier, at the August meeting, he'd told the room that "inflation risks are very real, and I believe that these are higher than growth risks."

Three months later, to the day, the Fed had cut rates to near zero.

That governor was Kevin Warsh. He runs the Fed now.

On December 9, his Fed is expected to raise rates again. Last week another Fed governor said a half-point hike should be on the table, and gold had its worst week since June.

So I went back through what the Fed said in the summer of 2008 and what gold did while it was saying it.

In August 2008, the Fed's Next Move Was a Hike

That August meeting was on the 5th, 41 days before Lehman.

Oil had hit a record above $147 a barrel in July. By the day of the meeting it was down to $119, a drop of 19%. But consumer prices were up 5% from a year earlier, and the next report, due the following week, would show 5.6%, the highest since 1991.

The Fed held at 2% and said the upside risks to inflation were "of significant concern." One member voted against the decision because he wanted to raise rates right then.

The minutes were blunter. Members generally expected their next move to be a tightening, which is how the Fed says "hike."

When the full transcripts came out years later, a reporter counted the words. At that meeting, inflation came up 322 times. Unemployment came up 28 times, and the risk of a financial crisis came up 19.

To be fair to them, they had a case. Inflation really was 5%, and nobody in that room knew Lehman had six weeks left.

But oil had already rolled over, and Bear Stearns had already been rescued in March.

After Lehman, the Fed cut to 1.5% on October 8, in an emergency move with five other central banks. Three weeks later it cut to 1%. On December 16 it went to a range of zero to 0.25%, the lowest in its history, and by then it had also announced plans to buy up to $600 billion of mortgage debt.

It took 133 days to get from "our next move is a hike" to zero.

Last Week, a Fed Governor Asked for a Half Point

Now look at last week.

Last Tuesday, Fed governor Christopher Waller gave a speech in London. He said he was leaning toward a quarter-point hike in December either way. And if core inflation (prices without food and energy) came in at 0.3% or more for the month, a hike of 50 basis points, or half a percentage point, "should be considered at the December meeting."

A few hours after he spoke, the October inflation report showed core prices up 0.3%, for the third month in a row.

His reason was the Fed's reputation. Hiking only a quarter point, he said, "would put our credibility at risk."

The Fed has leaned on that word before. In June 2008, less than three months before Lehman failed, the head of the Philadelphia Fed argued for getting ready to hike "or our credibility could soon vanish."

Traders took him at his word. By Friday the market had priced a December hike as a sure thing, with roughly a one-in-eight chance of the half point.

The two-year Treasury yield, the number I showed you how to read last Wednesday, went from 4.51% to about 4.86% in five trading days. It hasn't jumped that much in a week since October 2024.

The 10-year closed around 5.15%, and the dollar finished at its highest level since March of last year.

Gold doesn't pay interest. So when Treasuries pay more and the dollar buys more, gold gets sold. It fell 4.6% on the week and settled Friday at $3,886 an ounce, below the low it made on October 30.

That's gold's lowest close since September of last year, and it leaves the metal about 30% below its January high of $5,513.

Oil Has Already Dropped 19%, Same as August 2008

So what would the Fed be hiking into?

Start with oil, since that's where this inflation came from. Brent crude closed Friday at $95.84 a barrel, about 19% below its high of the past month. That happens to be how far oil had fallen by the day of that August 2008 meeting.

Then look at the people paying the bills. Sales of existing homes fell in October to an annual pace of 3.75 million, the slowest since August 2010, with the average 30-year mortgage at 7.33%.

The New York Fed reported last week that Americans owe a record $1.29 trillion on their credit cards, and that 12.9% of those balances are at least 90 days past due.

None of this means another Lehman is 41 days away. Nobody can know that, the Fed included.

But I think it's making the same mistake it made that summer. The last time the Fed stared at an oil-driven inflation number while credit was cracking behind it, the hikes never came, and four months later rates were at zero.

The current chairman had a seat at the table for all of it. You'd think he'd remember.

Gold Fell 30% in 2008 Too

Now, what did gold do through all that?

It fell hard.

Gold crossed $1,000 for the first time on March 17, 2008, at $1,011 an ounce. By October 24 it was $712. That's a drop of about 30%, straight through the worst financial panic since the 1930s.

The miners did worse, as they usually do. The main index of gold-mining stocks lost about 70% between March and late October.

I explained why this happens in Why Gold Fell With the Tech Stocks. When people get scared they sell what they can, and anyone who borrowed to invest gets a margin call and has to sell whether he wants to or not. Gold's about as easy to sell as it gets.

If you own gold expecting it to jump the day the trouble starts, 2008 says you'll be disappointed.

The move came afterward. The Fed went to zero and started buying bonds, and gold was back above $1,000 within a year. By September 2011 it was near $1,900, more than two and a half times that October 2008 low.

The people who got paid were the ones who still owned it.

The Miners Held a Line Gold Didn't

Gold closed below its October 30 low last week, and the miners didn't. I didn't expect that.

The biggest gold-miners fund fell harder than gold on the week and still finished above where it bottomed on October 30. So did the junior miners and the silver miners.

Normally it goes the other way. When gold breaks to a new low, the miners tend to get there first.

It's one week. I wouldn't hang a decision on it.

But there's a detail from 2008 I keep in mind. The mining stocks hit bottom on October 27 of that year, seven weeks before the Fed got to zero, and by New Year's Eve they'd roughly doubled.

Stocks tend to move on what's coming. If the miners are right, the market doesn't believe this Fed can hike for long.

The central banks aren't waiting to find out. China's central bank has now added gold for 24 months in a row, and October's purchase was its biggest since it started buying again. I showed you on Friday what the rest of them did with the drop.

As for me, I bought a lot of gold in May 2020 and watched it trade below what I paid two years later. I didn't sell an ounce.

I've had gold, silver and the miners on our list since April 9, 2025, and last week doesn't change that.

One Move: Find Out What Could Force You to Sell

Here's the one thing I'd do this week.

Go through your accounts and look for anything that could make you sell at a bad time.

Plenty of the people who lost money on gold in 2008 got forced out of it, down 30%, a few months before it turned. There are two places that usually comes from.

Borrowed money. If you've borrowed against your brokerage account, whether it's margin or one of those credit lines banks offer against a portfolio, a big drop can trigger a call that sells your position for you. It'll do it near the low, because that's when the calls go out.

Money with a deadline. Anything you'll need in the next year, for tuition or a down payment, doesn't belong in gold miners. They fell 70% in 2008 before they doubled.

If you find either one, fix it now, while it's still your choice.

If it were me, I wouldn't sell gold because a Fed governor wants 50 basis points. The Fed says it's hiking and the market believes it, so the next few weeks could be rough for anything that doesn't pay interest. But I'd rather own gold before the Fed changes its mind than try to buy it after, because by then the price has usually moved.

I think this Fed ends up where the 2008 Fed did. I just can't tell you whether that takes four months or fourteen.

Later this week, I'll show you the $1.6 billion mining deal Washington just walked away from, and what the new Congress can and can't do to the rest.

What Premium Members Get Today

Everything above is free and yours to keep.

Below, Premium Members get Friday's buy alert, with a name, a price, where the watch price sits, and the five things that would make us sell. They also get a straight answer on our first rare-earth pick after its quarter.

Here's the record behind our calls:

17 closed trades. 16 winners. Average gain 72.3%.

Since our first alert in March 2025, the S&P 500 is up about 32%.

Premium is just $35 a month. If you want it even cheaper, go for the annual option at $300 a year ($25 a month). When you join now, Friday's buy alert is waiting for you when you log in.

Double D

P.S. Here's a screenshot of the current Moonshot Minute Portfolio. I've blurred out the tickers since that information is only for Premium Members, but you can see how we've done so far:

🔓 Premium Content Begins Here 🔒

In today's Premium Section: Friday's buy alert. A name, a price, a watch price and the five things that would make us sell, plus a straight answer on our first rare-earth pick after its quarter. If you're not a Premium Member yet, you'll want to join today.

I hope you’ve been paying attention because many of our picks are currently beating the S&P by up to 4-to-1 over the last 12 months.

Most financial newsletters charge $500, $1,000, even $5,000 per year. Why? Because they know they can.

I don’t.

I built my wealth the old-fashioned way, not by selling subscriptions.

That’s why I priced this at $35/month, or $300/year.

Not because it’s low quality, but because I don’t need to charge the typical prices other newsletters charge.

One good trade, idea, or concept could pay for your next decade of subscriptions.

The question isn’t ‘Why is this so cheap?’ The question is, ‘Why would I charge more?’

P.S. If this newsletter were $1,000 per year, you’d have to think about it.

You’d weigh your options. You’d analyze the risk.

But it’s $35 a month.

That’s the price of a bad lunch decision.

And remember, just one good idea could pay for your subscription for a decade.

Recent comments from Premium Members:

Amazing! Moonshot is hands down the best $150 decision I have ever made. Up 64% on TICKER REDACTED (so far). Can't thank you enough for your service, advice, recommendations, insight, and every other positive accolade in the dictionary.

Very respectfully and gratefully,

CK

I’m up 71% in 6 weeks would you recommend adding to this bucket if capital allows?

MS

Hello Double D,

As it happened, I already owned some TICKER REDACTED shares when you recommended the stock. Upon your recommendation, I bought more. All told, I'm up over 70% in a month or two.

I greatly appreciate the detailed discussion you and your team provide for your recommendations.

Thank you.

A happy subscriber,

PK

I finally got some liquidity I could use and bought the stock as well as March 2026 calls yesterday morning (October 2nd) when it was at $17.80.

That is easily the best-timed investment/trade I've ever made, and I have your team's perpetual hard work and research to thank for it.

Thanks again for all the hard work. You and your team push out a lot of solid research, and the effort doesn't go unnoticed.

It is greatly appreciated,

MD

Closing at 24% gain, and enough profits to pay for 2yrs of your newsletter. Thank you for this! I especially appreciate you detailing the rationale behind your picks. As a newer investor it’s important for me to know why just as much as what.

MS

Up 68.87% on TICKER REDACTED to date, great recommendation!

BW

Thanks for the great tip on TICKER REDACTED! I bought, and just eight trading days later, it's up 52% as of this very minute. I'm new to your newsletter, less than two months, but I have found it to be quite soundly researched and a truly invaluable source.

I've been actively investing for many years and have, at one time or another, subscribed to various investment advisors. None have been as useful (nor as affordable!) as the Moonshot Minute.

You, sir, do excellent work and we individual investors much appreciate it.

SD

Up 66%! Thanks.

SB

Kudos and thank you for the TICKER REDACTED recommendation. TICKER REDACTED has been awesome and I do understand/believe this to possibly be only the beginning. I bought 200 shares at $16 and another 100 at $18, the day before the surge started. Again, I am very grateful.

RH

I've only been with you a few weeks now, and overall, my portfolio is up 41%. Couldn't have done it without you, DD. Thanks again.

HJP

I joined your plan about 2 months ago.

TICKER REDACTED was a real hit - and I did fully realize it yesterday for a rise - 141%. Great deal!!

IS

Just wanted to drop you a quick THANK YOU! Been a member for about a week (I wanted to see your picks for the electrical asymmetry) and I picked up some TICKER REDACTED & TICKER REDACTED. I’m already up $1,300.00 so my membership is covered for 5 years in about a week!

Keep up the great work! Again, THANKS! Glad to be a subscriber!

RH